PB&J Cookie Wonders

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies are an exquisite treat that transcends generations, bringing the beloved flavors of a classic childhood sandwich into an irresistible dessert form. These delightful cookies feature a luscious, creamy strawberry buttercream frosting nestled between two perfectly baked, soft, and chewy peanut butter cookies. It’s a nostalgic journey with every bite, offering a perfect blend of sweet, salty, and fruity notes that captivates taste buds of all ages. If you love peanut butter cookies, prepare for an elevated experience that’s truly unforgettable!

While we cherish the simplicity of traditional peanut butter cookies, we’ve discovered that pairing them with a vibrant strawberry frosting takes them to an entirely new level of deliciousness. And when you stack two of these heavenly cookies, bound together by that sweet, fruity buttercream, you create a cookie sandwich that’s not only visually appealing but also a textural masterpiece. These Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies aren’t just a dessert; they’re a celebration of flavor, texture, and pure comfort, making them an ideal treat for any occasion, from casual family gatherings to festive holiday spreads.

Crafting the Perfect Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies

The journey to these exceptional sandwich cookies begins with a meticulously crafted peanut butter cookie recipe. Our cookies strike the perfect balance: wonderfully soft and tender in the center, with just the right amount of delightful chewiness around the edges. This ideal texture is achieved through a thoughtful combination of both butter and shortening in the dough. Butter contributes to that rich, classic flavor, while shortening plays a crucial role in ensuring the cookies maintain their shape beautifully during baking, preventing excessive spread, and enhancing their irresistible softness. The result is a robust yet delicate peanut butter cookie that serves as the perfect foundation for our flavorful filling.

Once your golden-brown peanut butter cookies have emerged from the oven and cooled completely to room temperature, the magic truly begins with the strawberry buttercream frosting. This decadent filling requires just a few simple ingredients: softened butter, confectioners’ sugar (also known as powdered sugar), and your favorite strawberry jam. Whipping these ingredients together creates a light, airy, and incredibly smooth frosting bursting with sweet berry flavor. The jam not only imparts a beautiful color but also adds that unmistakable “jelly” element, making these cookies a true homage to the classic PB&J. Once prepared, generously spread this delightful frosting between two cooled cookies and gently press them together to form your ultimate Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies.

Essential Tips for Perfect Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies

Achieving bakery-quality Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies is simpler than you might think with a few expert insights. These tips are designed to ensure your cookies are not only delicious but also beautifully presented and consistently perfect every time.

• Embrace the Cookie Scoop for Uniformity: Using a cookie scoop is not merely a suggestion; it’s a game-changer, especially when creating cookie sandwiches. By scooping out each portion of dough to the exact same size, you ensure that all your cookies bake evenly and, most importantly, line up perfectly when assembled. This uniformity is key for both aesthetic appeal and a balanced bite, preventing any lopsided or mismatched sandwiches.
• Customize Your Jam Choice: While strawberry jam is a classic choice for these delightful cookies, feel free to unleash your creativity! If grape jelly holds a special place in your heart, go for it! Perhaps raspberry jam appeals to your adventurous side. Any flavor you adore will be absolutely delicious. The most crucial tip here is to opt for a *seedless* variety of jam. Seeds, while natural, can disrupt the smooth and creamy texture of the buttercream frosting, making it less pleasant to eat and spread. A smooth jam ensures a silky, luxurious filling experience.
• Select the Right Peanut Butter: For optimal baking results, we strongly recommend using regular, creamy peanut butter brands like Jif or Skippy. These types of peanut butter are formulated with a consistent texture and oil content that performs reliably in baked goods. More “natural” peanut butters, which often separate and contain less added sugar, can lead to cookies that are greasier, crumbly, or spread too much. While creamy is our go-to, if you appreciate a subtle crunch in your cookies, feel free to use crunchy peanut butter. The small nut pieces will add an interesting textural contrast without compromising the overall structure.

Key Ingredients for Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies

Crafting these delectable sandwich cookies involves two main components, each with its own specific set of ingredients meticulously chosen for flavor and texture.

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE INGREDIENTS

• All-Purpose Flour: The foundational ingredient that provides the necessary structure to our cookies. Standard all-purpose flour works perfectly, ensuring a tender crumb.
• Baking Soda: This acts as a leavening agent, helping the cookies rise and achieve their characteristic soft texture. Always check that your baking soda isn’t expired for best results.
• Salt: A small but mighty ingredient, salt is essential for balancing the sweetness and enhancing the rich flavors of the peanut butter and sugars, making them “pop.”
• Unsalted Butter (Softened): You’ll need 1/4 cup (half a stick) of unsalted butter, softened to room temperature. Butter contributes immensely to the flavor and tenderness of the cookies.
• Shortening: Also 1/4 cup. Shortening is crucial for preventing excessive spread and ensuring the cookies remain soft and chewy, holding their perfect sandwich shape. Crisco sticks are particularly convenient for easy and mess-free measurement.
• Granulated Sugar & Brown Sugar: A harmonious blend of white and brown sugars contributes to both sweetness and texture. Granulated sugar provides crispness, while brown sugar adds moisture, chewiness, and a subtle molasses flavor. Ensure your brown sugar is fresh and soft for optimal results.
• Creamy Peanut Butter: The star of the show! Use regular creamy peanut butter (such as Jif or Skippy) for the best texture and consistency in baking. If you prefer a slight crunch, crunchy peanut butter can be substituted. Avoid “natural” peanut butters, as their oil separation can negatively impact the cookie’s structure.
• Large Egg: A single large egg acts as a binding agent, bringing all the ingredients together and adding richness and moisture to the cookie dough.

STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM FROSTING INGREDIENTS

• Unsalted Butter (Softened): One full stick (1/2 cup) of softened unsalted butter forms the creamy base of your delectable frosting.
• Powdered Sugar (Confectioners’ Sugar): Approximately 3 1/2 cups of powdered sugar are needed to achieve the perfect sweet and creamy consistency for a pipeable and spreadable buttercream.
• Seedless Strawberry Jam: The “jelly” component! About 2/3 cup of seedless strawberry jam infuses the buttercream with vibrant fruity flavor and a beautiful pink hue. Remember, any seedless jam can be used to customize the flavor.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Make Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies

PREPARING THE PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE DOUGH

1. Begin by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C). This ensures a consistent baking temperature from the moment your cookies enter the oven.
2. Line two standard baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats. This crucial step prevents sticking and promotes even baking and easy removal.
3. In a medium-sized mixing bowl, whisk together the dry ingredients: all-purpose flour, baking soda, and salt. Set aside.
4. In a separate, larger mixing bowl, using an electric mixer on low speed, beat together the softened butter, shortening, granulated sugar, and brown sugar until the mixture is light, fluffy, and creamy. This process usually takes about 3 minutes. Scrape down the sides of the bowl as needed to ensure all ingredients are well incorporated.
5. Add the creamy peanut butter and the large egg to the wet mixture. Continue to beat on low speed for another 2-3 minutes, until everything is smoothly combined and the mixture is well aerated.
6. Gradually add the whisked flour mixture to the wet ingredients, a little at a time. Beat on low speed until the flour is *just* combined with the wet ingredients. Be careful not to overmix, as this can lead to tough cookies. Scrape down the sides and bottom of the bowl frequently to ensure uniform mixing.

SHAPING THE COOKIES

7. Utilize a 2-tablespoon sized cookie scoop to portion out the dough. Roll each scoop into a smooth, uniform ball. This recipe should yield approximately 18 dough balls, which will make 9 sandwich cookies.
8. Arrange half of the cookie dough balls evenly spaced on each prepared baking sheet, allowing room for slight spreading.
9. Using the back of a fork, gently press down on the tops of each cookie dough ball to create the classic crisscross pattern. Try your best to press them all down to a similar thickness; this aids in even baking and ensures consistent size for sandwiching.

BAKING AND COOLING THE PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES

10. Bake the cookies for 8-10 minutes, or until their bottom edges are lightly set and just barely starting to turn golden brown. It’s important to note that the cookies will still appear very soft in the center when you remove them from the oven; this is perfectly normal and desired for a chewy texture.
11. Allow the cookies to cool for 5 minutes directly on the baking sheet. This “carryover cooking” allows them to firm up slightly without becoming overly crispy. After 5 minutes, carefully transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely. They must be entirely cooled before frosting to prevent the buttercream from melting.

PREPARING THE STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM FROSTING

12. While your peanut butter cookies are cooling, it’s the perfect time to prepare the luscious strawberry frosting.
13. In a clean mixing bowl, beat the softened butter until it’s light and creamy. Gradually add the powdered sugar, beating until the mixture is smooth, fluffy, and well combined. This process typically takes about 3-4 minutes.
14. Finally, mix in the seedless strawberry jam. Stir on low speed until the jam is just fully incorporated into the buttercream, resulting in a beautifully colored and flavored frosting.

ASSEMBLING THE COOKIE SANDWICHES

15. Once the peanut butter cookies are completely cool, it’s time for assembly. You can either pipe the frosting onto the flat side of half the cookies using a piping bag with your favorite tip for a professional look, or simply use a knife or small offset spatula to spread a generous amount onto each cookie.
16. Gently top the frosted cookies with the remaining half of the cookies, pressing down lightly to create your perfect cookie sandwiches. Serve these delightful treats immediately for the best fresh experience.

PEANUT BUTTER AND JELLY SANDWICH COOKIES

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies are made by spreading a creamy strawberry buttercream frosting between two soft and chewy peanut butter cookies. Your favorite childhood sandwich in the form of a dessert that everyone loves!

Print
Pin
Rate

Course:
Cookies

Cuisine:
American

Keyword:
Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwiches

Prep Time:
10 minutes minutes

Cook Time:
10 minutes minutes

Servings:
9 cookie sandwiches

Calories:
702kcal

Author:
Jessica & Nellie

Ingredients

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE INGREDIENTS

• 1 ½ cups flour
• ½ teaspoon baking soda
• ¼ teaspoon salt
• ¼ cup butter softened
• ¼ cup shortening
• ¼ cup granulated sugar
• ½ cup brown sugar
• ⅔ cup creamy peanut butter
• 1 large egg

STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM FROSTING INGREDIENTS

• ½ cup butter softened
• 3 ½ cup powdered sugar
• ⅔ cup seedless strawberry jam

Instructions

MAKE THE COOKIE DOUGH

1. Preheat oven to 350°.
2. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats.
3. Whisk flour, baking soda and salt together in a mixing bowl.
4. In a separate bowl, beat butter, shortening, granulated sugar and brown sugar on low until light and creamy (about 3 minutes).
5. Add in the peanut butter and egg and mix for another 2-3 minutes.
6. Adding the flour mixture a little at a time, beat on low until just combined, scraping down the sides and bottom of the bowl as needed.

SHAPE THE COOKIES

7. Use a cookie scoop (2 tablespoon size) to scoop out the dough and then roll it into balls. You should be able to make 18 balls of dough.
8. Place half of the cookie dough balls on each baking sheet.
9. Using the back of a fork, make crisscross patterns on the tops of each cookie, pressing down gently. Try your best to press them all down to the same thickness.

BAKE AND COOL THE PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES

10. Bake 8-10 min or until the bottom edges are set and just barely starting to brown. They will still be very soft.
11. Allow the cookies to cool for 5 minutes on the baking sheet, then transfer them to a wire rack until fully cooled.

MAKE THE STRAWBERRY FROSTING

12. While the cookies are cooling, make the strawberry frosting:
13. Beat butter and sugar until light and creamy. This should take about 3-4 minutes.
14. Mix in the jam and stir just until combined.

ASSEMBLE THE COOKIE SANDWICHES

15. When the cookies are cool, pipe the frosting onto half the cookies and top with the other half of the cookies. You can also just use a knife to spread it.
16. Serve cookie sandwiches. If you are not planning to serve/eat them within an hour or two, store the cookies and frosting separately. The cookies can be kept in an airtight container at room temperature, but the frosting should be stored in the refrigerator until ready.

Nutrition

Calories: 702kcal |
Carbohydrates: 102g |
Protein: 7g |
Fat: 32g |
Saturated Fat: 13g |
Polyunsaturated Fat: 5g |
Monounsaturated Fat: 11g |
Trans Fat: 1g |
Cholesterol: 59mg |
Sodium: 349mg |
Potassium: 178mg |
Fiber: 2g |
Sugar: 77g |
Vitamin A: 499IU |
Vitamin C: 2mg |
Calcium: 36mg |
Iron: 2mg

Tried this recipe?
Mention @familycookierecipes or tag #familycookierecipes!

Optimal Storage for Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie Sandwiches

Proper storage is key to maintaining the freshness and deliciousness of your Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies. Whether you’re preparing them ahead of time or simply enjoying leftovers, these guidelines will help ensure they taste great for longer.

If you have already assembled your cookie sandwiches and have leftovers, they should be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator. The buttercream frosting, due to its dairy content, benefits from refrigeration to maintain its texture and prevent spoilage. When stored correctly in the fridge, these assembled cookies can last for up to 3-4 days, though they are always best enjoyed fresh.

For optimal freshness, especially if you are not planning to serve all of the cookie sandwiches shortly after making them, it is highly recommended to store the cookies and frosting separately. The baked peanut butter cookies can be kept at room temperature in an airtight container for up to 5-7 days. The strawberry buttercream frosting should be stored in a covered container in the refrigerator, where it will remain fresh for about a week. When you’re ready to serve, simply allow the frosting to come to room temperature (or very slightly warmer if it’s too firm to spread, a quick whip with a spoon will restore its creaminess), and then assemble the cookie sandwiches right before enjoying. This method ensures both the cookies and the frosting retain their ideal textures and flavors.

Pro Tips for Baking the Best Peanut Butter Cookies

Mastering the art of baking truly exceptional peanut butter cookies involves a few crucial techniques that can elevate your results from good to absolutely outstanding. Pay attention to these details for consistently perfect cookies:

• Perfectly Softened Butter is Non-Negotiable: This is arguably one of the most critical steps in cookie making. Butter that is too cold and hard won’t cream properly with the sugars, leading to a dense cookie. Conversely, butter that is too warm or melted will result in a greasy dough and cookies that spread too much and become flat and crispy. The ideal consistency for softened butter is cool to the touch but yields easily to a gentle press, leaving an indentation. If you have the luxury of time, simply leave your butter on the kitchen counter for 1-2 hours. For those impromptu baking urges, you can carefully soften butter in the microwave. Use very short bursts (5-10 seconds at a time) on a low power setting (like defrost), checking after each interval. The goal is to soften, not melt. The defrost setting can be particularly effective for even softening.
• Always Preheat Your Oven: A properly preheated oven is vital for consistent cookie results. Placing cookie dough into a cold or partially heated oven will affect how the cookies spread and bake, often leading to uneven cooking, over-spreading, or a tough texture. Always allow your oven to reach the specified temperature and stabilize for at least 10-15 minutes before inserting your baking sheets.
• Invest in a Cookie Scoop for Precision: Beyond just achieving uniform size for perfectly matched sandwich cookies, a cookie scoop ensures that each cookie receives the same amount of heat exposure, leading to even baking. It also makes the process faster, cleaner, and more efficient, making it a valuable tool for any regular baker.
• Utilize Parchment Paper or Silicone Baking Mats: These non-stick surfaces are essential for hassle-free baking. They prevent cookies from sticking to the baking sheet, ensuring easy removal without breaking or altering their shape. Furthermore, they promote more even heat distribution, which contributes to consistent baking and a beautifully golden-brown bottom crust. Cleanup is also significantly simplified!
• Resist the Urge to Overbake: This is a common pitfall that can turn a soft, chewy cookie into a hard, dry one. Peanut butter cookies should typically be removed from the oven when their edges are just barely set and starting to turn a very light golden brown, even if the centers still look slightly underbaked and soft. Cookies continue to bake and firm up for a few minutes after being removed from the hot oven due to residual heat, a process known as “carryover cooking.” Trust the process; if you wait until they look fully baked in the oven, they will likely be overbaked once cooled.

Expert Advice on How to Soften Butter Correctly

Softening butter might seem like a straightforward task, but doing it correctly is crucial for the success of many baking recipes, especially cookies and frostings. The goal is to achieve a pliable, room-temperature consistency without any melted spots, which can throw off the delicate balance of your dough or buttercream.

My preferred method for consistently perfect softened butter is using the defrost function on the microwave. This setting generally provides a gentler, more controlled heat, reducing the risk of accidental melting. If you need a full stick (1/2 cup) of butter, you can often leave it in its paper wrapper, but if you’re using a smaller amount or wish to be extra cautious, place the required portion in a glass or porcelain bowl. Set your microwave to its lowest defrost setting and start with an interval of 20 seconds. After this initial burst, check the butter’s softness by gently pressing it with a rubber scraper or your finger. It should yield easily, leaving a slight indentation, but there should be no shiny, melted edges. If it’s still too firm and doesn’t indent, return it to the microwave for additional short intervals of 5-10 seconds, watching it very closely. Butter can go from perfectly softened to slightly melted surprisingly quickly. The key is patience and vigilance. This careful approach ensures your butter is uniformly softened, creating the ideal foundation for light, airy frostings and perfectly textured cookies.

Craving More Peanut Butter Cookie Creations? We’ve Got You Covered!

If you’ve fallen in love with the rich, comforting taste of peanut butter in these delightful sandwich cookies, then you’re in for a treat! Our collection is brimming with other fantastic peanut butter cookie recipes that are sure to satisfy any craving. From classic favorites to innovative twists, there’s a peanut butter cookie for every occasion and palate. Explore these irresistible options and find your next go-to recipe:

• Easy Peanut Butter Cookies
• Fudge Peanut Butter Cookie Cups
• Best Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Cookies
• Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies
• Peanut Butter Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Best Monster Cookies
• Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Cups
• Five Chip Peanut Butter Oatmeal Cookies
• Peanut Butter Cookie in a Mug
• Reese’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Reese’s Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies
• Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
• Fluffernutter Cookies
• Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cookies

There’s simply nothing quite like the joy of a homemade cookie, and these Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cookies take that joy to an entirely new level. With their soft, chewy peanut butter base and a burst of creamy strawberry buttercream, they’re a dessert that delights both young and old. Enjoy creating these wonderful treats!